After reading an earlier post about how great someone thought E.L.F’s Mineral Makeup was I had to try it. It sounded wonderful, and for only 5 smackers it wouldn’t be a total loss if I wasn’t crazy about it. Besides, I have plenty of friends who are just waiting for all the products I try but don’t love to be gifted to them. I prefer to buy my friends off the old fashioned way instead of earning them, it’s so much easier
I popped over to the website and immediately added the lightest color (fair) mineral makeup to my cart. It can be hard to tell color on a website, but it looked like it just might work. Since I had those great codes to choose from at check out, I decided to buy a few brushes as well. I’ve bought some inexpensive brushes from Target before that I’ve been quite fond of, and for only a dollar apiece I think these qualify as inexpensive as well. It couldn’t hurt right? Some of the brushes had rave reviews on the website, particularly the eye shadow brush. Not wanting to miss out on a good thing, I ordered 3 of those. I also tacked on a liner brush, an all over face brush, and a smudge eye sponge.
Hit checkout, entered my info, and waited for my package to arrive. Thanks to one of the spiffy codes we were supplied with, my total was only around $16 and $6 of that was shipping! I’d like to add here that my package arrived in under a week, which is better than some other major companies I’ve purchased cosmetics from recently.
Of course I ripped open my package and the mineral makeup as soon as it arrived. I couldn’t wait to see it! The minerals come in a 1.2 oz package. No matter how small you think that is, it’s actually smaller. It would be easy to carry around in your purse, but it looks a little disappointing when you first open it. When I first applied it I thought it made my pores look far more noticeable, not a great first impression. The color was also a little off, matching more closely with the picture of the “light†makeup than the “fair†I was expecting. Be aware if you order it that it does run a bit darker than the picture on the site.  Many people who wrote reviews had the same problem and suggest getting the “fair†mineral concealer instead.  After a few minutes it seemed to settle in and my pores were less visible. The coverage was good and the feeling of the powder was smooth, and I really like that it has a soft dewy look instead of the matte you see so often. It left me with a radiant natural look. My friend who received the excess noticed the poor color match on me, so while I was sad to let it go I know it was for the best. With a lighter offering for fair skin tones I would happily purchase this again. I would hesitate to rank it up there with Everyday Minerals, but it’s a very good product for the money.
The brushes seemed to be hit or miss. I took the face brush out of its package and shook it against my hand to puff it out a bit and the top popped right off in the process! I’m no fragile flower, but I’m not that strong either. I always recommend having some Gorilla glue around, and it sure came in handy fixing this brush. The bristles of the brush were very long but not very dense, leaving powders to get lost in the brush instead of applied to your face. The liner brushes were pretty standard, perfect for the popsicle stick method Jen learned from Laura Mercier. It would be nice to see them in a narrower size for some of my gel liners and such. I have to admit that the eye shadow brushes are pretty fantastic. The short dense bristles hold an ample amount of product and keep it on the brush instead of allowing it to fall on your cheeks. I got good solid color application. My only gripe is that there was a rough spot one some of the bristles on one brush. Some of the glue perhaps? Altogether not a huge disappointment from a $1 brush though. Well worth the money to stock up on a bunch and refresh your brush supply if need be.
I’ve not yet tried the shadows and other products from E.L.F., but with the decent showing by these products I wouldn’t hesitate to try them in the future. They have a nice red gloss I’ve got my eye on. I know there are many of you out there who have taken advantage of their amazing prices, so please help out your fellow deal seekers and let us know what you thought!
10 Responses for "FGW: E.L.F Products. Or, You get what you pay for?"
I ordered a couple of their hypershine lip glosses. I like that they stay on really well and don’t run off my lips. They do kind of have a funny taste though and after kissing my dh with some on he was wigging out. LOL.
I’ve been looking for some new eyeshadow so I bought 4 and a compact. I like the strength of the colors. I have a hard time with the purples and greens I have looking gray on my eyelids. These seem to actually stay the color they’re supposed to be. I’m really liking them.
I tried a color stick and it’s okay. I use it for cheeks, but it doesn’t seem to rub in very well. If it rub it in enough the color disappears, but if I leave it so some color shows, it feels like I’m wearing make-up.
I also got the shimmer mineral glow. I thought it might be a little like the Bare Essentials Mineral Veil. It’s more shimmery than I was expecting, but I like it.
Over all I’m really happy with my purchases, especially the eyeshadow. After recently plunking down $20 for a Stila green eyeshadow only to have it look gray on my lids, I was super-pleased that the ELF’s sage eyeshadow stayed green and was $19 cheaper. I’ll definitely be buying it again when I run out.
Woah. That was kinda long and wordy. Sorry.
You are so great HSF! What awesome reviews. Please BE LONG AND WORDY anytime.
Best to you, Mr. HSF, and Peanut!
Hmmm. Right up my budget alley- but I think I bought the wrong stuff. The eyeshadow I picked up with in a case, pre-pressed, and it didn’t stay on at all.
David alos complained about the taste of the lipshine stuff.
I suppose I should have picked up some brushes, too…
Now I am curious about the flavor of this lip gloss. Is it chemically weird or what? Sounds like e.l.f. is a mixed bag of great and not so great finds. Thanks for your input Tracy!
The only complaint I have about E.L.F. is that the color “swatches” online aren’t very true. I thought the shadows ended up being a lot duller in person. And the brightening eye pencils aren’t very creamy. I guess Kohl costs more than $1.
I like elf a lot… for the price they have some pretty ok make up.I use their lip glosses a lot..and i enjoy their eye liners. The only things that I can do without is the eyeshadows. Some break and some appear too sparkly. But i do want to try the mineral make up. I’ve tried loreal’s and it left my face with that chalky look. Not cute on wedding day!
I bought a few things about a week ago, it didn’t take long to get here, about a week (it came on a Saturday, which is cool).
I got the Tone Correcting Concealer in Light, I figured it would be a match because I’m super pale body wise but not face wise so I figured settling in the middle would work but it didn’t, it was too dark, I was a bit disappointed that the color on the website was way off compared to what came in the mail but for a dollar it’s not that big a deal.
I also bought three Nail Polishes. I got one in Clear just because I was in need of a clear nail polish and it works just fine. I also got Gum Pink, it looks exactly like what’s on the website, it’s a bit watery but it’s a very fun bubble gum pink. Then I also got Berry Pink, again it looks exactly like what’s on the website, it has shimmers and it’s really pretty, but it again is kind of watery so you’ll probably need to put two coats if not more.
The Shine Eraser works great, I don’t get very oily (but I’m preparing for summer) so I use them on my boyfriend. You get fifty sheets for a dollar so it’s a great deal especially when I compare that price to that of Too Faced (which I almost bought for $12).
The Eye Widener is a descent investment. It can be hard to get on your eye so you have to rub in on your hand to warm it up, but it really does give your eyes that bigger, brighter look. The cap has a built in sharpener, which is pretty handy though I don’t know if it works. So for a buck it’s a pretty good deal.
I figured for a dollar it was worth to try all the brushes so I got the Professional Complete Set of 12 Brushes (you don’t save any money for buying sets, 12 brushes for 12 dollars). Some were goods, others weren’t as great, I haven’t used some of them yet though. My favorite so far has to be the Brow Comb and Brush for clumps on my eye lashes and the Eyelash & Brow Wand, they made my eyelashes huge and gorgeous. There was some gunk (I have no clue what it was it looked like a gel or maybe a glue?) on some of the brush handles, and also some scratches, it’s not that big a deal but a little annoying for me since I like my things looking perfect.
The last thing I bought was Mineral Eye Shadow ($3 each) in Celebrity, it looks like an orange brown on the website but when you get it it’s so gorgeous, it’s kind of copper looking with some purple undertones. It’s really shimmery though, and I haven’t used it yet so I can’t tell you if it’s good but the color is so pretty.
Also if you give up three of your friends’ e-mail addresses you get a free Candy Shop Lip Tin (usually sell for $2), I was hoping I would not get the Mocha Maniac because I hate the smell of coffee but of course I got the one I didn’t want, I tried it on my hand and it looks like it would be pretty on your lips but the smell is too overwhelming for me.
I’ll let you know about the other things I’m ordering.
About the all over color sticks, I was having the same problem (with them looking too fake) but if you use a light powder over them it lightens them out and make them more natural, at least for me. Hope that helps.
Ah! I reeeally want to try elf makeup and brushes! I currently have the WoRsT brushes in the world! I’m too afraid to wash them because they shed so much so they are full of powder, it’s gross. So anyways, i just recently started wearing makeup and I don’t have a whole lot of money so elf would be great. If anyone has any good natural makeup ideas and some good cheap black eyeliners, that would be great! Just email me please!
Leave a reply